Jason Bateman has the remarkable gift of being immensely likable in everything he does, capable of buoying mediocre material with his irresistible charm. I just love the guy, and that is precisely why I tolerated Horrible Bosses. Seth Gordon's raunchy comedy about three frustrated employees (Bateman, Jason Sudeikis, Charlie Day) who hatch a plan to kill their three demonic bosses has an inspired premise, but it fails to capitalize on its potential. There are some funny moments, and the movie is pretty entertaining throughout, but it suffers from a disheartening wealth of missed opportunities. Horrible Bosses is not as funny as it should be, nor is it as daring as it should be, considering the dark and ambitious premise. But the film stays afloat thanks to Mr. Bateman, a supremely talented and affable performer who always excels, regardless of the quality of material that he is given. Horrible Bosses does feature some terrific supporting performances, most notably from Jason Sudeikis of Saturday Night Live fame, Jamie Foxx as a strange ex-con, and from the three evil bosses (Jennifer Aniston, Kevin Spacey, Colin Farrell). Aniston's portrayal of a sex-obsessed dentist is particularly amusing. But it is Bateman who saves the day, maintaining consistent entertainment value in a film that could have been a bigger success.
And then there is Bad Teacher, a mean-spirited and surprisingly dull disappointment that tries to create an endearing figure out of a wholly unlikable character. At least I think that's what Bad Teacher is trying to do. It's all part of the aggravating ambiguity of this misguided comedy. The cast, for the most part, is not the prolem. The lovely Cameron Diaz gives it her all, but she can't make a likable character out of an alcoholic gold digger of a teacher who drills kids with dodgeballs and tells insecure boys that they have no shot of winning over the pretty girl. The always hilarious Jason Segel delivers some of the movie's only big laughs as a single gym teacher with a crush on Cameron Diaz. John Michael Higgins, Phyllis Smith, Lucy Punch, and Eric Stonestreet all give admirable efforts with characters that are thinly conceived. The usually reliable Justin Timberlake, however, is grating as a shockingly clueless teacher who has no intellect whatsoever. And did I mention that there is a lengthy dry-humping scene? Bad Teacher is a letdown from director Jake Kasdan, who directed the very funny 2002 film, Orange County.
